Keinänen, M. & Tahko, T.E. (2019)

Bundle Theory with Kinds

In this paper, which is an exercise in formal ontology – an area of research concerning fundamental ontological categories and their relations – Markku Keinänen (Tampere) and Tuomas Tahko examine the tempting idea that there could be just one fundamental ontological category. The most famous attempts to get by with just one ontological category are versions of ‘universal bundle theory’, where property universals bundled together constitute all the familiar objects, making it unnecessary to commit to category of ‘substance’. One of the most developed versions of this idea is L.A. Paul’s mereological bundle theory.   Keinänen & Tahko argue that Paul’s attempt to construct a one category ontology may be challenged with some of her own arguments. In the positive part of the paper, a two category ontology with property universals and kind universals is outlined. Keinänen & Tahko also examine Paul’s arguments against a version of universal bundle theory that takes spatiotemporal co-location instead of compresence or coinstantiation as the feature by which we can identify genuine bundles. The novel theory, bundle theory with kinds, is compared with Paul’s mereological bundle theory and applied to a case study concerning entangled fermions and co-located bosons.   

< Latest news

< Publications

The Philosophical Quarterly

The Philosophical Quarterly is one of the most highly regarded and established academic journals in philosophy. In an age of increasing specialism, it remains committed to publishing high-quality articles from leading international scholars across the range of philosophical study. Accessibility of its content is an editorial priority.